Theories Proven Wrong

Go down

Theories Proven Wrong

Post by marasama on 16th March 2011, 5:17 pm

Basically, before the discovery of extrasolar planets, theories on a solar system (using our Sol System as a model) dictated the following:

1) Gas Giant cannot exist before the Snow Line, or at least close in. (Proven: FALSE)
- Hot Jupiters.

2) Neptune size planets are rare. (Proven: FALSE)
- Kepler-11 system & HD 6930 system.

3) Planet radius will not exceed Jupiter size radius. (Proven: FALSE)
- As for Bloated Gas Giants.

4) Planets form nearly circular orbits. (Proven: FALSE)
- HD 96167 b

5) Planets cannot exist around Neutron stars and White Dwarf stars (Post-stars). (Proven: FALSE)
- PSR B1257+12 system.

6) With minor exceptions, everything in a star system should orbit in the same plane and in the same direction. (Proven: FALSE)

Any other theories you know, I will add.
Not sure of these:
- Planets that orbit a binary star or cirumbinary orbits can't exist.
- Planets don't orbit ahigh inclined orbit.
- Planets don't form like stars, via gas collapse.

Three Theories of Planet Formation Busted, Expert Says, National Geographic.

CarpD (^_^)

Number of posts : 215
Location : Earth
Registration date : 2008-04-22

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Back to top

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum