Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Page 1 of 1 • Share •
Which will be first to detect an ~Earth-mass planet?
Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Not a lot going on, so I decided to ask what everyone thought about what would be the first group to detect an Earth-mass planet.
Transiting/non-transiting, habitable/hellish, doesn't matter. Just as long as it's mass is ~ 1 M_earth.
Edit: With the announcement of Gliese 581 e, I think I should refine "~ 1 M_earth" to be any planet whose mass is between 0.9 M_earth to 1.1 M_earth, as stated in a post after this.
Transiting/non-transiting, habitable/hellish, doesn't matter. Just as long as it's mass is ~ 1 M_earth.
Edit: With the announcement of Gliese 581 e, I think I should refine "~ 1 M_earth" to be any planet whose mass is between 0.9 M_earth to 1.1 M_earth, as stated in a post after this.
Last edited by Sirius_Alpha on Wed Apr 22, 2009 7:10 pm; edited 2 times in total
_________________
Conspiracy theories aren't real, the government just wants you to think they are so they can steal your thoughts when you aren't looking.

Sirius_Alpha- Admin

- Number of posts: 983
Location: Earth
Registration date: 2008-04-06

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
THE RUSSIANS!!!!!!!!!!
_________________
I'm a renegade, fear me!

NuclearVacuum- Planetesimal

- Number of posts: 148
Age: 19
Location: Delta Trianguli
Registration date: 2008-07-06

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Does this count?
Sure, the 1 Earth mass case lies at the end of the 2-σ range, but you never know...
Thus, our discovery of MOA-2007-BLG-192Lb represents the first discovery of an extrasolar planet with a planetary mass ratio orbiting an extremely low-mass primary that is likely to be a brown dwarf, and with a mass of m = 3.3+4.9−1.6 M⊕ (or a 2-σ range of 1.0–18 M⊕)
Sure, the 1 Earth mass case lies at the end of the 2-σ range, but you never know...
Lazarus- Jovian

- Number of posts: 581
Registration date: 2008-06-13
Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
I voted for OGLE, and MOA-2007-BLG-192Lb helps support my thought.
_________________
Thanks,
CarpD (^_^)

marasama- Planetesimal

- Number of posts: 121
Location: Earth
Registration date: 2008-04-22
Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Haha, I suppose I should have been more accurate.
1 M_earth as in "We're pretty dang confident it's ~1 +/- 0.1 M_earth". I don't quite understand standard deviation enough to phrase it in that context haha.
An interesting note that CoRoT currently has no votes.
Do I smell a space race about to start?

An interesting note that CoRoT currently has no votes.
NuclearVacuum wrote:THE RUSSIANS!!!!!!!!!!
Do I smell a space race about to start?
_________________
Conspiracy theories aren't real, the government just wants you to think they are so they can steal your thoughts when you aren't looking.

Sirius_Alpha- Admin

- Number of posts: 983
Location: Earth
Registration date: 2008-04-06

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
NuclearVacuum wrote:THE RUSSIANS!!!!!!!!!!
And why not ITALIANS????

Edasich- Saturn-Mass

- Number of posts: 491
Age: 25
Location: Tau Ceti d - Northern hemisphere
Registration date: 2008-06-02

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
I voted for Kepler , but ... Spaniards got a chance from ground observations too 
ciceron- Rock

- Number of posts: 33
Age: 40
Location: Spain
Registration date: 2008-04-08

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
so that planet orbiting MOA-2007-BLG-192Lb; any hints on whether or not it's a terrestrial or gas planet?
i like the potential in a 3-5 earth mass planet
gremlin66- Micrometeorite

- Number of posts: 6
Age: 29
Location: Canada, Earth
Registration date: 2009-04-20
Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
The planet is most likely a terrestrial planet.
_________________
Conspiracy theories aren't real, the government just wants you to think they are so they can steal your thoughts when you aren't looking.

Sirius_Alpha- Admin

- Number of posts: 983
Location: Earth
Registration date: 2008-04-06

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
But do not expect to find there the little green men. With a brown dwarf host the habitable zone is certainly tight (<<0.1 AUs) so it should be as cold as Uranus or Saturn.

Edasich- Saturn-Mass

- Number of posts: 491
Age: 25
Location: Tau Ceti d - Northern hemisphere
Registration date: 2008-06-02

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Who would be the first to detect an Earth-mass extrasolar planet? As far as methods go, I would say Doppler method.
Earth-mass extrasolar planets are already detectable with today's technology. Maybe not around stars like the Sun, but definitely doable around red dwarfs.
Consider Gliese 581e. The mass (or more precisely, the value of m sin i) is 1.9 Mearth. The star, Gliese 581, has a mass of 324 Mjup. Extrapolating from that point, an Earth-mass exoplanet would be detectable, with today's technology and using the doppler method, around a 170 Mjup star in a 0.03 AU orbit. Finding an Earth-mass exoplanet orbiting a star with a mass of 80 Mjup with the doppler method would be trivial with today's technology.
Earth-mass extrasolar planets are already detectable with today's technology. Maybe not around stars like the Sun, but definitely doable around red dwarfs.
Consider Gliese 581e. The mass (or more precisely, the value of m sin i) is 1.9 Mearth. The star, Gliese 581, has a mass of 324 Mjup. Extrapolating from that point, an Earth-mass exoplanet would be detectable, with today's technology and using the doppler method, around a 170 Mjup star in a 0.03 AU orbit. Finding an Earth-mass exoplanet orbiting a star with a mass of 80 Mjup with the doppler method would be trivial with today's technology.
AVBursch- Hydrogen Atom

- Number of posts: 4
Registration date: 2009-05-01
Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
Once you get in the mass ranges you're talking about, the stellar host is a brown dwarf and is very dim. There is a problem getting radial velocity data from the star with a sufficiently high signal to noise ratio.
_________________
Conspiracy theories aren't real, the government just wants you to think they are so they can steal your thoughts when you aren't looking.

Sirius_Alpha- Admin

- Number of posts: 983
Location: Earth
Registration date: 2008-04-06

Re: Who will be first to detect Earth-mass planet?
I voted CoRoT, I guess because it's had the most luck as far as stuff not around red dwarfs.

Dnoces- Hydrogen Atom

- Number of posts: 4
Registration date: 2009-04-26
Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum





