PSR B1257+12 D: extrasolar dwarf planet?
Page 1 of 1 • Share •
Should this planet (if confirmed) be clasified as an "extrasolar dwarf planet"?
PSR B1257+12 D: extrasolar dwarf planet?
Now that the Solar system contains five dwarf planets, I would like to bring up an opinion poll on PSR B1257+12 D. Because of its mass and presumable size, should this planet be classified as the first "extrasolar dwarf planet"? I do mean should we use this definition if the planet is confirmed. 


NuclearVacuum- Planetesimal

- Number of posts: 148
Age: 19
Location: Delta Trianguli
Registration date: 2008-07-06

Re: PSR B1257+12 D: extrasolar dwarf planet?
I'd say yes. According to the estimator in this paper, this object would not clear its orbital neighbourhood within a Hubble time. The calculation basically boils down to
Λ≈1.7×1016(Mp/M⊙)2a-3/2
for a solar mass star. Planets (in their terminology, überplanets) have Λ>1, dwarf planets (in their terminology, unterplanets) have Λ<1. I'm not entirely sure how to translate this to other stellar masses, but it seems there is an additional scaling of Ms1/2, which would mean
Λ≈1.7×1016(Ms/M⊙)(Mp/Ms)2a-3/2
For the outer object orbiting PSR B1257+12, this works out as Λ<1, so it looks like it is not a planet. The remaining question is whether it is in hydrostatic equilibrium - if the true mass is high enough, then yes, make it a dwarf planet.
Λ≈1.7×1016(Mp/M⊙)2a-3/2
for a solar mass star. Planets (in their terminology, überplanets) have Λ>1, dwarf planets (in their terminology, unterplanets) have Λ<1. I'm not entirely sure how to translate this to other stellar masses, but it seems there is an additional scaling of Ms1/2, which would mean
Λ≈1.7×1016(Ms/M⊙)(Mp/Ms)2a-3/2
For the outer object orbiting PSR B1257+12, this works out as Λ<1, so it looks like it is not a planet. The remaining question is whether it is in hydrostatic equilibrium - if the true mass is high enough, then yes, make it a dwarf planet.
Lazarus- Jovian

- Number of posts: 581
Registration date: 2008-06-13
Re: PSR B1257+12 D: extrasolar dwarf planet?
I dunno.
Has it cleared out it's orbital path?
Has it cleared out it's orbital path?
Darkness nova- Asteroid

- Number of posts: 69
Location: Octans
Registration date: 2008-06-12
Re: PSR B1257+12 D: extrasolar dwarf planet?
If a dwarf planet can be viewed as a world that has planet-like characteristics, but does not have sufficient mass to be a full-fledged planet, then the outermost known world of PSR B1257+12 would be a dwarf planet. The world has 21% of the mass of Pluto -- that's definitely well within the mass range for a dwarf planet.
As for clearing it's orbital neighborhood -- not likely. The pulsar has 1.4 (presumed) times the mass of the Sun, and the world has a semi-major axis almost three times that of Earth. At a distance of 2.8 AU from the pulsar, a world would likely need to have at least 5 times the mass of Pluto in order to establish dynamical dominance.
As for clearing it's orbital neighborhood -- not likely. The pulsar has 1.4 (presumed) times the mass of the Sun, and the world has a semi-major axis almost three times that of Earth. At a distance of 2.8 AU from the pulsar, a world would likely need to have at least 5 times the mass of Pluto in order to establish dynamical dominance.
AVBursch- Hydrogen Atom

- Number of posts: 4
Registration date: 2009-05-01
Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum



